Farm lease disputes
When owner and tenant disagree about rent, maintenance, improvements or the end of the lease, mediation can settle it before the season is lost.
What these disputes look like
A farm lease runs for years, and a lot changes in that time. The disagreements I see most often are about:
- rent that is late, or that one side believes should change;
- who must maintain fences, roads, dams, pumps and buildings;
- improvements the tenant made, and whether the owner owes anything for them;
- how the land is being farmed, grazed or rested;
- notice, renewal, and the condition of the farm when it is handed back;
- arrangements that were agreed on a handshake and never written down.
Why mediation suits a farm lease
Owner and tenant usually still have to deal with each other tomorrow. They are often neighbours, sometimes family. A court case can take longer than the lease has left to run, and while it drags on, the land, the crop and the relationship all suffer.
Mediation is faster and far cheaper than court, and it stays private. It also lets you agree on things a court cannot order, such as a new rent, a maintenance plan, a longer term or an orderly way to part.
How I approach it
I farm in the Upper Langkloof, so I understand what a season, a camp or a borehole is worth. I speak to each side first, then bring you together at a neutral venue. Bring the lease, if there is one, and any letters or messages that matter; I will tell you beforehand what is useful. We work through the issues one at a time, in joint sessions and in private sessions with each side. If you reach agreement, it is written up and signed on the day.
What you can rely on
Nothing said in mediation can be used in court. You decide the outcome, not me. And if you do not reach agreement, you have lost none of your rights.
Common questions
Our lease was never put in writing. Can we still mediate?
Yes. Many farm arrangements are verbal. Mediation helps you agree on what the arrangement is from here on, and the outcome can be put in writing so that it is clear for both of you.
Can the agreement change the lease?
If you both agree, yes. Parties often use mediation to settle new terms such as rent, duration or who maintains what. You are welcome to have your attorney check the wording before you sign.
The lease ends soon. Is there enough time?
Most mediations are planned for a single day, so it can usually be arranged far sooner than a court date. [TODO: George to confirm typical lead time]
Related
Water and irrigation disputes
Water turns, shared dams, furrows and pipelines: disputes between neighbours who will still share the same water next year.
Talk it through first
A short call costs nothing and commits you to nothing. Whatever you tell me is treated as confidential.